The remnants of Jayville, New York offer a window into the past. This abandoned community, which once held the dreams and ambitions of its settlers, now stands as a historical marker of New York’s development. Its weathered structures tell stories of prosperity, hardship, and eventual decline.
County: Not available
Zip Code: Not available
Latitude / Longitude: Not available
Elevation: Not available
Time Zone: Not available
Comments: Not available
Remains: Not available
Current Status: Not available
Remarks: Not available
Jayville, New York stands as a fascinating example of a boom-and-bust ghost town in the Adirondack region, with a history deeply intertwined with the iron mining industry of the 19th and early 20th centuries. Located in the southwest part of St. Lawrence County, this former hamlet emerged as a mining community in 1850 and experienced a brief period of prosperity before various economic and practical challenges led to its abandonment. Today, only scattered remnants and historical records testify to Jayville’s existence, offering a window into the industrial development and subsequent decline of small communities in upstate New York.
Origins and Early Development
Jayville’s story begins in the 1850s when Zebulon H. Benton first opened the area for iron ore mining in 1854. The hamlet was situated on what would eventually become the Carthage and Adirondack Railroad line, positioning it as a potentially significant industrial center. However, the early years of mining at Jayville saw limited activity, with relatively small amounts of ore being extracted from the site.
The earliest documented use of ore from Jayville dates back even further, to 1833, when a blast furnace built by the Fuller brothers at Fullerville used magnetic ores from both Jayville and Clifton. Similarly, in 1855, the Alpine Hot-blast Charcoal furnace, owned by Z.H. Benton of Oxbow, utilized black magnetite from the Jayville bed mixed with red hematite ore from other sources.
Despite these early uses, significant development of Jayville would not occur until the 1880s, when improved transportation infrastructure made large-scale mining operations more feasible. The hamlet’s fortunes were closely tied to the expansion of the railroad network in northern New York, with Colonel Benton playing a crucial role in advocating for rail connections to the Jayville mines.
The Railroad Era and Mining Boom
One of the most significant events in Jayville’s history occurred in 1884 when New York State commissioned the building of the Carthage and Adirondack Railroad to run from Carthage to Jayville. This railroad, completed in 1887, transformed the hamlet’s prospects by providing a direct transportation link for the iron ore extracted from its mines. The railroad was later extended to Benson Mines in 1889, further integrating Jayville into the regional transportation network.
The arrival of the railroad coincided with a brief mining boom in Jayville during the 1880s. In 1886, upon completion of the railroad to Jayville, the property was leased from Benton by the Byron D. Benson interests. Operations continued under the name of the Magnetic Iron Ore Company until 1888, during which time the mines produced significant quantities of magnetite ore.
The ore extracted from Jayville was noted for its high quality. Specimens of magnetic ore from the Jayville mine were showcased at the Iron Ores of the United States Philadelphia Exhibition in May 1877, where they were described as ‘very rich.’ Analysis of samples taken in 1881 identified various compositions of magnetite, sometimes associated with pyroxene, pyrite, or other minerals.
The magnetic properties of the ore in Jayville led to the development of new mining techniques. The use of magnetic separation methods allowed for the processing of lower-grade ores, potentially extending the productive life of the mines. However, despite these technological advances, the Jayville mines faced significant challenges that would ultimately lead to their abandonment.
Decline of Mining and Transition to Lumber
By 1888, the Magnetic Iron Ore Company had invested substantial resources in developing the mines at Jayville and securing property at Little River (now Benson Mines). However, it became increasingly apparent that ore of good quality could not be extracted from the Jayville mines in economically viable quantities. The company made the strategic decision to abandon the Jayville operations in favor of the deposit at Little River, where they established a large concentrating plant and extended the railroad.
The decline of mining in Jayville was further accelerated by legal complications. In 1892, costly litigation over mineral rights and railroad tariffs that traveled through private land owned by Proctor (in a case known as Proctor vs. Benson) effectively halted mining operations in the hamlet. This legal dispute represented a significant setback for Jayville’s primary industry and forced the community to adapt to changing economic circumstances.
Following the decline of mining, Jayville transitioned to a lumber-based economy in the 1890s. Several sawmills were established in the hamlet, providing alternative employment for residents and a new economic foundation for the community. Throughout the 1890s and into the early 1900s, Jayville survived primarily on railroad traffic and sawmill industries, demonstrating the resilience of small communities in the face of economic shifts.
Attempted Revival and Final Decline
In 1914, there was an attempt to revive mining operations in Jayville. According to historical accounts, a Mr. Howard Hughes (not the famous aviator and industrialist) purchased the mines property and invested significant resources in pumping water out of the old pits. The goal was to reach the ‘mother lode’ of ore believed to be located under Twin Ponds. However, this endeavor proved challenging as water continuously seeped into the mines, filling them as quickly as they could be pumped out. After operating at a loss for approximately three years, Hughes closed the mines, marking another setback for Jayville’s industrial prospects.
The final assessment of Jayville’s mining potential came in 1941 when the Jones & Laughlin Steel Corporation conducted extensive geological surveys of the area. The company drilled eight inclined holes with a total length of 2,366 feet, with most holes reaching depths of 200 to 250 feet, and several extending to 350 to 450 feet. Based on this exploration, Jones & Laughlin concluded that the property held little interest as a potential producer of lump ore, effectively ending any serious consideration of resuming mining operations in Jayville.
With both mining and lumber industries in decline, Jayville gradually lost its economic reason for existence. According to Wikipedia, by the year 2000, ‘all residents had moved out of the community and it’s been a ghost town ever since.’ The final blow to the hamlet may have been a fire, which reportedly ‘ended the existence of the hamlet of Jayville,’ though the exact date and circumstances of this fire are not well-documented in available historical sources.
Community Life in Jayville
Beyond its industrial history, Jayville was a living community with social structures, educational institutions, and notable incidents that captured public attention. The hamlet had a railroad station that served as a hub for transportation and communication. The Jayville stop on the Carthage and Adirondack Railroad was labeled as 4E, and a telegrapher was stationed there to facilitate communication along the line. This position was a union job, organized under the Order of Railroad Telegraphers.
Education was provided in the hamlet, though details about the school system are limited in historical records. Religious services were likely conducted in private homes or community buildings, as there is little mention of formal church structures in Jayville. Hunting was a significant activity in the area, taking advantage of the abundant wildlife in the surrounding Adirondack forests.
One of the most sensational incidents in Jayville’s history occurred in 1895 and involved a case of vigilante justice that captured national attention. According to Cheri L. Farnsworth’s book ‘Wicked Northern New York,’ a woman named Hattie Covey became involved in an affair with John Kirch, a married local sawmill superintendent. After the couple allegedly ran away to Ohio for two months, Mrs. Covey returned to Carthage to visit her parents. In a disturbing turn of events, she was seized by a group of men and women (the latter disguised in men’s clothes with blackened faces), taken to the railroad freight house, stripped, and tarred and feathered.
The incident was reported in the New York Times on July 31, 1895, and in The Daily Journal on the same date, indicating the level of public interest in this act of frontier justice. According to these accounts, Mrs. Covey suffered serious injuries during the attack, including a broken arm and several broken ribs, though she ultimately survived. The perpetrators were eventually located, arrested, and put on trial in Pitcairn, reflecting the tension between vigilante action and formal legal processes in rural communities of the era.
Physical Layout and Remnants
Jayville was located at coordinates 44°9′15″N 75°11′20″W, as plotted by the U.S. Geological Survey in 1913. The hamlet was situated on what is now Jayville Road in St. Lawrence County, southeast of Harrisville. While the homes and most structures of Jayville have disappeared, some physical remnants of the hamlet can still be found.
Most notably, the former Carthage & Adirondack Railroad train depot reportedly remains standing along Jayville Road, providing a tangible link to the hamlet’s past. The abandoned railroad station is located on New York State-owned land, making it accessible to those interested in exploring this ghost town’s history. Other remnants might include foundations of buildings, mining equipment, or other artifacts, though these would likely be scattered and deteriorated after more than a century of abandonment.
The mines themselves, once the economic heart of Jayville, are now flooded and inaccessible. The challenging hydrology that contributed to the mines’ closure—with water continuously seeping into the excavations—has ensured that these industrial spaces have returned to a more natural state, though their presence is still marked in the landscape.
Legacy and Historical Significance
Jayville’s story, though not widely known outside of local historical circles, offers valuable insights into the economic and social development of the Adirondack region during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The hamlet’s rise and fall mirror broader patterns of industrial development, resource extraction, and community formation in rural America during this period.
The history of Jayville illustrates the boom-and-bust cycle common to many mining communities, where initial optimism about natural resources leads to rapid development, followed by decline when those resources prove less abundant or economically viable than initially hoped. The hamlet’s transition from mining to lumber industries demonstrates the adaptability of such communities, even as it highlights the precariousness of their existence when dependent on extractive economies.
Jayville also provides a window into the social dynamics of small, isolated communities in the late 19th century. The tarring and feathering incident of 1895, while shocking to modern sensibilities, reflects the complex moral codes and enforcement mechanisms that operated in such communities, where formal legal structures might be supplemented or even supplanted by community-based forms of justice.
Today, Jayville exists primarily in historical records, old maps, and the memories of those with connections to the region. Its story has been preserved through the efforts of local historians, archaeological investigations, and the documentation of ghost towns in New York State. While the physical town has largely disappeared, its legacy continues as part of the rich tapestry of Adirondack history.
Visiting Jayville Today
For those interested in exploring the remains of Jayville, the site is located off Jayville Road in St. Lawrence County, southeast of Harrisville. The former railroad station, reportedly still standing, provides a focal point for visitors. However, potential explorers should be aware that much of the former hamlet is now on New York State-owned land, and appropriate permissions and precautions should be taken before visiting.
The remote location and limited remaining structures make Jayville a destination primarily for those with a serious interest in ghost towns, industrial archaeology, or Adirondack history. Visitors should be prepared for rugged conditions and should respect both the natural environment and the historical significance of the site.
While Jayville may not offer the dramatic ruins or extensive remains found at some other ghost towns, its subtle traces in the landscape and its documented history provide a meaningful connection to the past for those willing to look beyond the surface. In this sense, Jayville exemplifies the quiet persistence of history in the Adirondack landscape, where the stories of past communities continue to resonate even after their physical presence has largely faded away.
Sources:
1. ‘Jayville, New York.’ Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jayville,_New_York
2. ‘Lost in the Adirondacks: Tarred and feathered in Jayville, N.Y.’ Sun Community News. https://suncommunitynews.com/news/96868/lost-in-the-adirondacks-tarred-and-feathered-in-jayville-ny/
3. ’19 Deserted and Forgotten Towns in New York.’ NewsBreak. https://www.newsbreak.com/a-z-animals-1693032/3116817874462-19-deserted-and-forgotten-towns-in-new-york
4. Farnsworth, Cheri L. ‘Wicked Northern New York.’
5. ‘Field Trip B-6 Zaykoski NYSGA 2014 206.’ New York State Geological Association. https://www.nysga-online.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NYSGA-2014-B6-History-and-Geology-Review-of-Magnetic-Iron-Mining-in-the-Western-Adirondacks.pdf
6. ‘Jayville Iron Mines Near Pitcairn, New York.’ The Diggings. https://thediggings.com/mines/21794
